A ‘retrospective preview’ of the Mousehole v St Austell Cornwall Senior Cup semi-final on Wednesday 5th March at Porthleven
As recalled by Andrew Large
Mousehole’s forthcoming Cornwall Senior Cup semi-final against St Austell brings back vivid and emotional memories from the clash between the same sides at the same stage of the Competition almost exactly seven years ago – on Wednesday 7th March 2018
What was it all about? In the 2017/18 season Mousehole were playing at Step 7 in the South West Peninsula League Division One West – three Leagues below where they are now. That season, they finished 4th with just three defeats in the last 24 matches – but it was their performance and results in the Cup competitions that stood out. They notched up ‘giant killing’ wins against several opponents from the League above, reaching the semi-finals of the SWP League Cup, with wins against Premier Division sides Camelford and Launceston in the earlier rounds before losing 2-0 to higher-league Tavistock at Mount Wise Newquay.
The icing on the cake! And right at the end of May they lifted the Cornwall Charity Cup for the second time in three years with a 5-0 humbling of Wadebridge Town at Penryn Athletic, remarkably the same scoreline as in their first triumph against St Dennis at Priory Park Bodmin in that sensational double-winning 2015/16 season.
But that’s not the most important bit! A much bigger and dramatic story unfolded in the Cornwall Senior Cup, the County FA’s prestigious 120-year-old knock-out competition.



There’s a first time for everything! Mousehole reached the semi-finals of the CSC for the first time in their near-100 year history with wins against lower-level Cornwall Combination League sides RNAS Culdrose and West Cornwall, followed by a spectacular 5-0 trouncing of Premier Division Newquay.
What about St Austell? The Lilywhites were undoubtedly one of the most impressive sides in the County at the time. Their recent history was peppered with successful achievements. They had become SWP Premier Champions and then Runners-up in consecutive seasons; reached the national FA Vase semi-finals before missing out on a Wembley Final appearance by the narrowest of margins over two legs; and in terms of their pedigree in the CSC they had claimed the trophy for an incredible 14th time.

The stage was set. The Mousehole/St Austell Senior Cup semi-final took place on a very wet evening on neutral territory at Helston Athletic’s Kellaway Park. It was then a rare occurrence for The Seagulls to play under floodlights, and equally rare to play in front of a crowd as big as the 381 on this occasion. The difference in status and track record between the two teams would have suggested a comfortable passage through to the Final for the illustrious Lilywhites. They would surely brush their opponents aside with their talented, strong and experienced squad. Maybe Mousehole, the minnows, would just have to be content with a sense of pride in participating?

How things turned out differently – the key moments:


Improbably, Mousehole take the lead in the 6th minute, Jake Andrew nodding a corner back from beyond the far post for Luke Johnson to lash a low drive home from ten yards.
Ominously, an equaliser arrives on 17 minutes as Martin Watts lofts an inswinging free kick towards the six-yard box in the direction of St Austell’s towering defenders, and Martin Giles powers home an unstoppable header.
If you are a Mousehole fan, you start to worry. But player/manager Calum Elliot’s cohorts keep their composure and give as good as they get up to half time.


Just after the hour, competitiveness boils over with St Austell’s Chris Reski provoking a mass confrontation after a violent tackle, earning himself a straight red card in the process.
Five minutes later it’s ten-versus-ten as Liam Andrew receives his second yellow card in the blink of an eye.
The greater space on the pitch now seems to suit Mousehole better, with careful stewardship of the ball and flexible movement on the slick surface.


Is this a significant moment? It’s a 75th minute substitute appearance of Steven Ziboth. A darting winger replacing a focal-point striker. Immediately, his energy, movement and pace keeps St Austell’s usually watertight defence guessing, twisting and turning.
Mousehole hit the woodwork before the end of regular time, but never mind that, a 1-1 scoreline is already a magnificent achievement for The Seagulls.
The half hour of extra time beckons, intriguingly.
It’s still level at the half-way point. Who, in the second period, will have most left in the tank, seize on a half chance, or make an unforced error? Could it end up with one of those nerve-wracking penalty shoot-outs?


Here’s the answer: On 115 minutes, Mousehole’s elegant Frenchman William Vouama slaloms past labouring defenders and chips a delicate pass into the path of his alert compatriot Ziboth for a cool low shot past keeper Jason Chapman. A 2-1 lead, and as this fascinating tie has progressed, now more deserved than unexpected: a triumph of skill, courage, decision-making and fitness.


But can the men in green hold on to their precious lead for the last five minutes, plus whatever’s added on? It’s hearts-in-mouth stuff past the 120 minutes mark as the entire St Austell team including keeper Chapman are up for a last-chance corner. Martin Giles’ header in a grid-locked penalty area is hacked off the line by Tyler Tonkin. Seagulls’ keeper Steve Parker-Billinge gets to the loose ball first. Instead of playing for time he instantly throws out to Steven Ziboth on the left. With the freedom of Kellaway Park ahead of him, and no defenders or the goalkeeper ever likely to catch him, the Usain Bolt of West Cornwall speeds towards the other end, ball seemingly tied to boot laces. For the rest of us on the sidelines, time stands still. We nearly stop breathing. But our man calmly rolls the ball into the unguarded net from the 18-yard line to clinch a 3-1 victory with 123 minutes on the stopwatch.


Seconds later, the final whistle: hugs, handshakes and hoarse voices from the sizeable and noisy Mousehole contingent – and a few tears in the eyes having witnessed first-hand this most improbable dream-come-true.

And so, on to a historic first-ever Senior Cup Final. “Giant-Killing Mousehole Soar Into Historic Cornwall Senior Cup Final” was the headline. The Final was on Easter Monday at St Blazey’s Blaise Park against serial Senior Cup winners Saltash United: a story for another time.
On to today – how times have changed! For this 2025 repeat encounter, Mousehole will be deemed favourites, being currently among the play-off promotion contenders at Step 4 in the Southern League. St Austell, plying their trade as a mid-table side at Step 5 in the Western League, will be the ones, this time, looking to turn the tables and create a giant-killing upset.
Players’ details
- St Austell’s team in 2018 included two players who have since become Mousehole stalwarts: Jack Calver and Mark Goldsworthy
- Of the Mousehole squad for that tie, two players are still at the club: Paulo Ranalli Sousa and Josh Otto – the latter an unused substitute on the night
- Mousehole’s line-up was: Steve Parker-Billinge (GK), Tyler Tonkin, Billy Curtis (Captain), Calum Elliot (Player-Manager), Liam Andrew, Kevin Lawrence, Jordan Adlard, William Vouama, Luke Johnson, Jake Andrew, Paulo Sousa. Substitutes: Steven Ziboth (for Jake Andrew 75’), Connor Davey, Caleb Marsden, Josh Otto.
- St Austell lined up as: Jason Chapman (GK), Will Tinsley, Martin Watts, Martin Giles, Tom Chambers, Ross Lye, Jordan Dingle, Chris Reski, Liam Dingle, Mark Goldsworthy, Jack Calver. Substitutes: Flack (for L Dingle 85’), Searle, Powell, Lean
Match Officials: Referee – Neil Hunnisett; Assistant Referees – Steve Nute & Keith Houghton; Fourth Official – Steve Ennis